Tuesday, February 16, 2016

Query Critique #8: INFLEXIBLE

My thoughts are added in redEvery comment is my own opinion. Readers, feel free to leave your own comments below and help a fellow writer out!

If you're interested in a Free Query Critique, follow the link for more information.

Original Version (with comments):

Dear Miss,

I'm seeking representation for "inflexible" (Usually in queries, titles are written in all caps, like INFLEXIBLE. Love the title by the way!) an 110,000 word science fiction (Capitalize “Science Fiction”) Dystopian novel (Is this adult, young adult, or middle grade? An agent needs to know the target audience up front. When you leave it blank, I’m assuming this is an adult novel),   where revenge story sets in the future world (Not quite sure what you’re trying to say with this sentence). I'm submitting to you because I've read  that you are interested in science fiction, diversity and political intrigues. Thus I hope my novel will capture your attention as well (Great job personalizing! I’d say if you are going to personalize it, you might want to go a step farther and mention some books the agent represents, etc. Obviously you’re only going to query an agent that is interested in science fiction!).

THOUGHTS ON PARAGRAPH 1: You did a good job introducing your book, word count, and genre as well as personalizing the beginning to the agent. I’m not sure you actually need the “where revenge story sets in the future world.” Instead, consider jumping into Paragraph 2 below. That is where your story starts!

In the future world only 7 seven (this is just personal opinion, but “7” really pops in a bad way in this paragraph when it’s written as a number. But it could just be me being silly!) countries have are left after the brutal war (“the” brutal war? Do you have any more information that could ground the agent? Also, you have to be super careful of typos and sentence wording. Agents are harsh, but they will be less likely to want to see a manuscript if the query letter is overly mess. Just a tip!). However in the country where Peter lives nobody should know about it (It being the war? Also, you might want to clue us in on how old Peter is). Population thinks that only two countries Suez and Sanisty are left and this two countries are playing dominant-submessive roles perfectly (This sentence has a few typos in it, you might want to look back and consider some rewording). However, the real mysteries are the secret computers, which built destroyed planet at the end of the war, but like everything has its price, these computers need biological bodies to work regular. A little main half-biological detail is inserted to the chosen kids bodies and all those kids are locked in special prison and are treated horribly.

THOUGHTS ON PARAGRAPH 2: Things are a little messy here. First of all you have to check your wording and grammar to keep things clear. Also, it’s a lot of telling. Could you show through action about these computers and quasi prison camps that the kids are forced to live in?

Peter managed to escape at age 11 and swore to revenge, however part of him wanted to live like a normal kid shall live (Okay, so that first paragraph was all backstory about Peter? How did he escape? One of the things you want to avoid in query letters is making the agent ask questions. The only thing they should be wondering is about how the story ends!). Clashing his two wishes made his personality split (huh?!). In the present Peter lives like a normal orphan boy which is raised by his uncle and heartless killer Josh at the same time. Peter knows everything about his dark side and because of that he's under a horrible stress. He has to decide what to do, to forever forget about his revenge or rejoin both his parts and complete his revenge. During his hesitation, things takes place in his life, which forces him face his past once again and go the deeper past of his countries. He knows, that path of his revenge, directly is connected to the period at the end of the war and if you dares to follow his path, he may forever destroy not only his life, but be the cause of Millions of death. 

THOUGHTS ON PARAGRAPH 3: This sounds like a very interesting plot! Things are just very bogged down as they are by typos and oddly phrased sentences. You might want to start at the beginning and rework how you want this query letter to flow. Ask yourself these kinds of questions:

1. Who is the main character? The agent needs their name, age, and something compelling about them that makes them interesting/relatable (this last point can be shown throughout the letter).

2. What characters have to be mentioned (i.e. are critical to the plot). You don’t want too many characters bogging down your query letter. You did a good job with that here!

3. What is the overall arching plot? It seems like your query letter is jumping around a lot. It’s important to start with the beginning of the story, instead of slogging through backstory.

"Inflexible" Is the first of planned series

Thank you for your time and consideration

Best wishes 

FINAL THOUGHTS: Like I said earlier, this does look like a very promising story, and I don’t want you to get discouraged with any changes that might need to be made—it’s all worth it in the end. Let me know if you want me to take a look at any edits that you make. Good luck with INFLEXIBLE!


post signature

No comments:

Post a Comment